WSU Energy Program Logo
Bonneville Power Administration Logo
  • Home
  • About
  • Database
      • Browse
      • Energy Systems
        • Building Envelope
        • Electronics
        • HVAC
        • Irrigation
        • Lighting
        • Motors & Drives
        • Multiple Energy Systems
        • Power Systems
        • Process Loads & Appliances
        • Refrigeration
        • Transportation
        • Water Heating
      • Sector
        • Agricultural
        • Commercial
        • Industrial
        • Residential
        • Utility
  • TAG Portal
      • 2017 Residential Lighting TAG (#14)
      • 2016 Multifamily Building TAG (#13)
      • 2015-1 Commercial HVAC TAG (#11)
      • 2014 Residential Building TAG (#10)
      • 2014 Commercial Building TAG (#9)
      • 2013 Information Technology TAG (#8)
      • 2013 ALCS TAG (#7)
      • 2012 Smart Thermostat TAG (#6)
      • 2012 LED Lighting TAG (#5)
      • 2011 Energy Management TAG (#4)
      • 2010 HVAC TAG (#3)
      • 2009 HVAC TAG (#2)
      • 2009 Lighting TAG (#1)
  • Webinars
    • Webinar Archives
  • Glossary
>

Summary

Thermochromic Windows

Window Glazing: Super-insulated Thermochromic vs. Conventional

Windows with coatings that automatically tint glazing during hot, sunny weather to reduce cooling load.

Synopsis:

Thermochromic glazing materials tint reversibly from a clear to dark tinted shade either passively in response to environmental conditions or actively in response to a command from a building automation system.  Some designs change from clear to tinted at a design temperature, others may gradually tint as temperature is increased.  Addition of a Low-E coating significantly improves the performance of thermochromic windows.  Field tests (in Colorado) indicate that thermochromic windows do not provide additional benefits in internal load dominated buildings with single-pane wood-framed windows (such as offices) above those achieved with conventional Low-E windows.  Occupant satisfaction with the windows may be negative if the tinting makes it appear "dark and stormy" outside during sunny days, when outside views are distorted, and when the windows present a mottled appearance---this can occur when temperature gradients occur i.e. if portions of the window do not react to solar gain due to localized shading due to overhangs while other areas are heavily tinted.  

The evolution of windows has moved from single pane to double pane, and now to triple pane.  “Super-efficient” triple pane windows can have R-values of R-5 or better, with a solar heat gain coefficient (SHGC) of less than 0.2. Code-minimum windows have an R value between 0.8 to R-2.86. Scores of manufacturers have now tested super-efficient windows per the National Fenestration Rating Council (NFRC).Ina typical medium-sized office building [as defined by the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)], with 33% glazing, the total energy bill could be shaved by 8% by replacing windows that meet code minimum standards (as allowed in 2006) with windows that are highly insulating (U-0.19) and good at shading the building’s interior from solar heat gain (SHGC-0.20).

Smart Windows from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) go several steps beyond triple pane windows; these thermochromic windows can block as much as 98 percent of direct sunlight, which can save on cooling costs.  Tests in Colorado indicate that replacing single-pane clear with thermochromic windows can provide HVAC cooling and heating savings of about 21% through modulating the amount of light coming through the glass in response to changing environmental conditions such as sunlight intensity or air temperature. 

Energy Savings: 21%
Energy Savings Rating: Not rated.  What's this?
LevelStatusDescription
1Concept not validatedClaims of energy savings may not be credible due to lack of documentation or validation by unbiased experts.
2Concept validated:An unbiased expert has validated efficiency concepts through technical review and calculations based on engineering principles.
3Limited assessmentAn unbiased expert has measured technology characteristics and factors of energy use through one or more tests in typical applications with a clear baseline.
4Extensive assessmentAdditional testing in relevant applications and environments has increased knowledge of performance across a broad range of products, applications, and system conditions.
5Comprehensive analysisResults of lab and field tests have been used to develop methods for reliable prediction of performance across the range of intended applications.
6Approved measureProtocols for technology application are established and approved.

Status:

Details

Thermochromic Windows

Window Glazing: Super-insulated Thermochromic vs. Conventional

Windows with coatings that automatically tint glazing during hot, sunny weather to reduce cooling load.
Item ID: 263
Sector: Commercial
Energy System: Building Envelope--Windows & Skylights
Technical Advisory Group: 2014 Commercial Building TAG (#9)
Average TAG Rating: 2.25 out of 5
TAG Ranking Date: 03/17/2014
TAG Rating Commentary:
  1. Second place to electrochromics for dynamic light and solar gain control. With the right applications it can be a good energy saver- but not as versatile as EC coatings; but potentially much cheaper. Needs additional field testing to verify best use and address potential limitations
  2. This is an interesting technology that has promise. It's success will depend on economics and market acceptance in terms of lighting quality and aesthetic issues, like the dark line in the middle of the glass pane, which also disturbs view.
  3. The catch is that any reduction in cooling load is offset by increased heating load as a result of cutting out sunlight during the cooler months. This is specific to the Pacific Coast.
  4. Poor ability to control, can hamper daylighting effectiveness         
  5. Reservations are based on the challenge of occupant control, inability to override the change in tint. Ease of implementation may suffer due to owner/design reluctance.
  6. May be integral to design of zero net energy buildings                     
  7. Program incentives can make this more accessible. Scores high on 'emerging' and 'ease of implementation' criteria.

Synopsis:

Thermochromic glazing materials tint reversibly from a clear to dark tinted shade either passively in response to environmental conditions or actively in response to a command from a building automation system.  Some designs change from clear to tinted at a design temperature, others may gradually tint as temperature is increased.  Addition of a Low-E coating significantly improves the performance of thermochromic windows.  Field tests (in Colorado) indicate that thermochromic windows do not provide additional benefits in internal load dominated buildings with single-pane wood-framed windows (such as offices) above those achieved with conventional Low-E windows.  Occupant satisfaction with the windows may be negative if the tinting makes it appear "dark and stormy" outside during sunny days, when outside views are distorted, and when the windows present a mottled appearance---this can occur when temperature gradients occur i.e. if portions of the window do not react to solar gain due to localized shading due to overhangs while other areas are heavily tinted.  

The evolution of windows has moved from single pane to double pane, and now to triple pane.  “Super-efficient” triple pane windows can have R-values of R-5 or better, with a solar heat gain coefficient (SHGC) of less than 0.2. Code-minimum windows have an R value between 0.8 to R-2.86. Scores of manufacturers have now tested super-efficient windows per the National Fenestration Rating Council (NFRC).Ina typical medium-sized office building [as defined by the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)], with 33% glazing, the total energy bill could be shaved by 8% by replacing windows that meet code minimum standards (as allowed in 2006) with windows that are highly insulating (U-0.19) and good at shading the building’s interior from solar heat gain (SHGC-0.20).

Smart Windows from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) go several steps beyond triple pane windows; these thermochromic windows can block as much as 98 percent of direct sunlight, which can save on cooling costs.  Tests in Colorado indicate that replacing single-pane clear with thermochromic windows can provide HVAC cooling and heating savings of about 21% through modulating the amount of light coming through the glass in response to changing environmental conditions such as sunlight intensity or air temperature. 

Baseline Example:

Baseline Description: Conditioned non-warehouse commercial building space
Baseline Energy Use: 10.5 kWh per year per square foot

Comments:

The 2009 Commercial Building Stock Assessment gives the actual electrical building energy use index (EUI) for various types of heating and cooling systems (Table D-EA5).  Office buildings with electric heating and cooling have an EUI of 20.1 kWh/sf/year.  Office buildings with no electric heating or cooling use only 8.2 kWh/sf/year, indicating that the combined HVAC heating and cooling energy use is 11.9 kWh/sf/year.  (For all commercial buildings, the corresponding numbers are 19.9 and 9.4 kWh/sf/year, respectively for a heating and cooling use of 10.5 kWh/sf-year).

Since this technology can be applied to many types of commercial buildings, a baseline heating and cooling energy use of 10.5 kWh/sf-year is assumed (NEEA, 12/21/2009). 

Manufacturer's Energy Savings Claims: Currently no data available.
Best Estimate of Energy Savings:

"Typical" Savings: 21%

Comments:

Energy Use of Emerging Technology:
8.3 kWh per square foot per year What's this?

Energy Use of an Emerging Technology is based upon the following algorithm.

Baseline Energy Use - (Baseline Energy Use * Best Estimate of Energy Savings (either Typical savings OR the high range of savings.))

Technical Potential:
Units: square foot
Potential number of units replaced by this technology: 11,080,263
Comments:

This technology could technically be used for virtually any commercial building (preferably with electric space heat to maximize electrical energy savings) except for warehouses and unconditioned space (84.7% x 27.1%, Table C-GB13) .  However, window installation will be most appropriate for just the south-and west-facing windows in the Northwest. The numbers for total commercial building space are taken from preliminary updated numbers from the 2013 update to the Commercial Building Stock Assessment (CBSA) using the estimates for 2014 (before the update was completed -- from early January, 2014), minus warehouse space, multiplied times the percentage of commercial space that is conditioned based on the 2009 CBSA, times our rough estimate of 50% of applicable space, which would count south-and west-facing perimeter zones plus half the interior space associated with those zones.

This number is further tempered as electrochromic windows can reduce only perimeter zone heating, ventilation, air conditioning, and lighting energy use.  The savings is decreased due to buildings already deploying tinted and/or Low-E windows and due to buildings that use occupancy sensors and daylighting controls.  The 2009 "Northwest Commercial Building Stock Assessment" indicates that 27.9% of commercial buildings have single layers of glazing.  In addition, 53% of the windows are tinted.  To reflect these constraints, the energy savings will be further reduced by 25% x 27.9% x 47% to yield an eligible square footage of 11,080,263 sf. 

 Total Floor space   -s.f. Warehouse   non-Warehouse   % Conditioned, Electrically Heated   % Applicable   Applicable Space 
 Source   (NEEA, 2014)  (NEEA, 2009 App C)   (NEEA, 2009 App C)   (NEEA, 2009 App D, Table D-EA1) WSU EP
 Values:           3,118,000,000      173,000,000       2,945,000,000 84.7% x 27.1% 50% 337,993,233

 Total Floor space   -s.f. Warehouse   non-Warehouse   % Conditioned, Electrically Heated   % Applicable   Applicable Space 
 Source   (NEEA, 2014)  (NEEA, 2009 App C)   (NEEA, 2009 App C)   (NEEA, 2009 App D, Table D-EA1) WSU EP
 Values:           3,118,000,000      173,000,000       2,945,000,000 84.7% x 27.1% 50% 337,993,233


Regional Technical Potential:
0.02 TWh per year
3 aMW
What's this?

Regional Technical Potential of an Emerging Technology is calculated as follows:

Baseline Energy Use * Estimate of Energy Savings (either Typical savings OR the high range of savings) * Technical Potential (potential number of units replaced by the Emerging Technology)

First Cost:

Installed first cost per: square foot

Comments:

The cost for thermochromic window film is estimated to be about $16/sf above that of a Low-E window in a mature market.  Note: this is per square foot of film (not floor area).

Cost Effectiveness:

Simple payback, new construction (years): N/A

Simple payback, retrofit (years): N/A

What's this?

Cost Effectiveness is calculated using baseline energy use, best estimate of typical energy savings, and first cost. It does not account for factors such as impacts on O&M costs (which could be significant if product life is greatly extended) or savings of non-electric fuels such as natural gas. Actual overall cost effectiveness could be significantly different based on these other factors.

Reference and Citations:

Joe Verrengia, 01/22/2010. Smart Windows: Energy Efficiency with a View
National Renewable Energy Laboratory

NEEA, 01/01/2014. Total Pacific Northwest Building Stock Based on Preliminary Numbers from the 2013 Update to the CBSA
Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance

CADMUS, 12/21/2009. Northwest Commercial Building Stock Assessment (CBSA): Final Report
Prepared by the CADMUS Group for the Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance

U.S. DOE, 04/05/2011. Making Smart Windows Smarter
U.S. Department of Energy

LBL, 01/01/2014. Smart Windows
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Rong-Hua Ma, 12/30/2011. BIPV-Powered Smart Windows Utilizing Photovoltaic and Electrochromic Devices
Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI)

Dariush Arasteh, 05/22/2006. Zero Energy Windows
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

LBL, 01/01/2006. Advancement of Electrochromic Windows
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

University of Minnesota , 01/01/2011. Windows for high-performance commercial buildings
University of Minnesota

Katherine Bourzac, 07/19/2012. Smart Glass Made In One Step
Chemical & Engineering News

Lauren Sommer, 05/25/2012. Energy-Saving Windows Get Smarter
QUEST Northern California

Alok Pradhan, 01/01/2010. Lovins GreenHome 1.0: Factor Ten Engineering Case Study
Rocky Mountain Institute

NFRC, 01/01/2014. Certified Products Directory
National Fenestration Rating Council

Eleanor Lee, 12/01/2014. A Pilot Demonstration of Electrochromic and Thermochromic Windows in the Denver Federal Center, Building 41, Denver, Colorado
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Rank & Scores

Thermochromic Windows

2014 Commercial Building TAG (#9)


Technical Advisory Group: 2014 Commercial Building TAG (#9)
TAG Ranking: 36 out of 44 Technologies (2014 Commercial TAG strategies ranked separately)
Average TAG Rating: 2.25 out of 5
TAG Ranking Date: 03/17/2014
TAG Rating Commentary:

  1. Second place to electrochromics for dynamic light and solar gain control. With the right applications it can be a good energy saver- but not as versatile as EC coatings; but potentially much cheaper. Needs additional field testing to verify best use and address potential limitations
  2. This is an interesting technology that has promise. It's success will depend on economics and market acceptance in terms of lighting quality and aesthetic issues, like the dark line in the middle of the glass pane, which also disturbs view.
  3. The catch is that any reduction in cooling load is offset by increased heating load as a result of cutting out sunlight during the cooler months. This is specific to the Pacific Coast.
  4. Poor ability to control, can hamper daylighting effectiveness         
  5. Reservations are based on the challenge of occupant control, inability to override the change in tint. Ease of implementation may suffer due to owner/design reluctance.
  6. May be integral to design of zero net energy buildings                     
  7. Program incentives can make this more accessible. Scores high on 'emerging' and 'ease of implementation' criteria.


Contact
Copyright 2023 Washington State University
disclaimer and privacy policies

Bonneville Power Administration Logo